Handmade Soap vs. Commercial Soap, what are the differences, advantages, and disadvantages?

Soaps have been used for centuries as a means of cleansing the skin. Today, there are many different types of soaps available, including handmade soap and commercial soap. But what’s the difference between the two? Which one is better for your skin? In this article, we’ll explore the differences between handmade soap and commercial soap and help you decide which one might be the best choice for you.

Handmade Soap

Handmade soap is typically made from natural ingredients, such as essential oils, herbs, and plant-based oils. These ingredients are often chosen for their skin-loving properties, such as moisturizing, exfoliating, or soothing the skin. Handmade soap is often formulated with specific skin types in mind, such as oily, dry, or acne-prone skin. This can make it a good choice for people with specific skin concerns.

One of the biggest benefits of handmade soap is that it is often free from potentially harmful or irritating ingredients, such as synthetic fragrances, preservatives, or detergents. This can make it a good choice for people with sensitive skin or those who prefer natural products. Additionally, handmade soap can have a luxurious texture that can be more moisturizing than commercial soap.

However, not all handmade soaps are created equal. It’s important to look for handmade soaps that are made with high-quality ingredients and are formulated for your specific skin type and needs. Additionally, handmade soap can be more expensive than commercial soap, as it is often made in small batches and requires more time and effort to produce.

Commercial Soap

Commercial soap, on the other hand, is mass-produced and often contains synthetic ingredients, such as preservatives, fragrances, and detergents. While commercial soap can be effective for cleansing the skin, it may also contain ingredients that can be harsh or irritating, particularly for people with sensitive skin.

One of the biggest benefits of commercial soap is that it is often more affordable and widely available than handmade soap. It can be found in most grocery stores, drug stores, and big-box retailers, making it a convenient choice for many people. Additionally, some commercial soaps are formulated with specific skin types in mind, such as oily, dry, or acne-prone skin.

However, not all commercial soaps are created equal either. Some commercial soaps contain harsh or irritating ingredients that can strip the skin of its natural oils and cause dryness or irritation. It’s important to read the ingredient labels carefully and choose a soap that is free from potentially harmful ingredients.

Which is Better?

So, which is better, handmade soap or commercial soap? The answer to that question depends on your individual preferences and skin type.

If you have sensitive skin or prefer natural products, handmade soap may be a better choice for you. Handmade soap is often free from potentially harmful or irritating ingredients, and it can be formulated for your specific skin type and needs. Additionally, handmade soap can have a luxurious texture that can be more moisturizing than commercial soap.

It’s also important to note that certain individuals lacking education or scientific expertise may attempt to make and sell soap by solely relying on online tutorials. However, these soap makers often overlook legal requirements and compliance standards, resulting in the sale of unlicensed and untested mediocre products. Additionally, they may not have the necessary knowledge to source authentic raw materials with proper certifications meeting industry standards or to conduct adequate testing to ensure their finished products meet the necessary standards. This results in a serious problem despite the claims of being natural or organic.

Commercial soap is often more affordable and widely available than handmade soap. Some commercial soaps are formulated with specific skin types in mind and may contain ingredients that can help improve your skin condition.

What to look for?

The factors listed below will help you determine the correct soap and brand, whether it is commercial or handmade.

Packaging & Labelling – Following packaging and labelling regulations, demonstrate a brands ethical behaviour. In particular, transparency and safety for consumers should be the top priority. This can be achieved by providing a transparent list of all ingredients on the packaging to enable consumers to make informed decisions and avoid any potential allergic reactions or adverse effects.

Additionally, packaging should include essential details such as the manufacturing date, packed date, best before date, batch / lot number, manufacturer’s address and contact details, warnings, instructions for use, and any other relevant information to ensure consumer safety and satisfaction. Simply disregard the companies that don’t adhere to the packaging and labelling rules.

Safety of the Ingredient – What matters when it comes to ingredient quality is not whether it is natural, naturally derived, natural identical, or synthetic. Instead, the most important considerations are the safety and suitability of the ingredient for your skin. It’s crucial to ensure that the ingredient is not harmful and does not cause any allergies, irritations, or adverse reactions on your skin. Therefore, the quality and safety of the ingredient should be the primary concern when selecting skincare products.

Manufacturing License – Soap makers are aware that obtaining a manufacturing license is a time-consuming process that requires them to possess the necessary knowledge, skills, and competence. They must also adhere to strict standards, including maintaining a suitable premises, following SOPs, GMPs, and quality control measures, as well as procuring raw materials that meet certain specifications.

Additionally, soap makers must be knowledgeable about the Drugs and Cosmetics Act and Rules, as well as standards and specifications for raw materials and finished products, including labeling and packaging requirements. It is not advisable to purchase soap from unlicensed soap makers, and consumers should always check for the manufacturing license number on the packaging label. If the soap maker does not have a license, it may be best to avoid their products altogether.

Trustable Brand –

Reputation: Look for a brand that has a good reputation and positive reviews from other customers. This can be found through online reviews, social media, or word of mouth.

Transparency: A trustworthy brand will be transparent about their products, ingredients, and manufacturing processes. Look for brands that provide detailed information about their products on their website or packaging.

Quality: Look for brands that prioritize the quality of their products and use high-quality ingredients. This can be demonstrated through certifications or awards that the brand has received.

Customer service: A trustworthy brand will prioritize customer satisfaction and provide excellent customer service. Look for brands that have a responsive customer service team and offer a satisfaction guarantee.

Social responsibility: Look for brands that are socially responsible and prioritize sustainability, ethical practices, and giving back to their community or charitable causes.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the choice between handmade soap and commercial soap comes down to personal preference and individual skin type. Both options have their own unique benefits and drawbacks. Handmade soap is often made from natural ingredients and can be formulated for specific skin types and needs, but it can be more expensive and harder to find the right one for your skin type.

Checkout Yuvadhi’s Unique, Indigenous, Natural & Vegan Handmade Speciality Soaps

Mowrah Butter + Tamanu Oil Soap | Mowrah Butter + Neem Oil Soap | Mowrah Butter + Karanja Oil Soap | Nalpamaradi Soap | Activated Charcoal Soap | Tulsi + Aloe Vera Soap